The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year: A Murderously Festive Holiday Comedy

Date: Sunday, Dec. 21
Time: Doors 6:00 p.m. · Show 7:00 p.m.
Tickets: $110 (plus tax & fees)
Capacity: 100 guests (limited seating)

Silver bells are ringing for a seasonal stand-up performance… until the jolly jokester is tragically upstaged by a murder! The holiday humbug is high, and it’s up to you—the unamused audience—to unravel this festive whodunnit.

You’ll gather clues, interrogate suspects, and bribe your fellow guests to solve the crime before this comedy act becomes a tragedy. Trade the Santa hat for a detective hat, because this mystery is more tangled than last year’s Christmas lights!

What to expect

  • Interactive, theatrical murder mystery with a holiday theme
  • A delicious three-course dinner while you solve the crime
  • Festive holiday attire or “ugly” holiday sweaters (encouraged, not required)
  • Limited-capacity experience for prime immersion

Reserve your seat before this “yuletide homicide” sells out.

MENU

FIRST COURSE

  • Carrot + Cardamom Tartare (V) / Finely diced carrots delicately seasoned with warm cardamom
  • Chopped Caesar Salad
  • French Onion Soup/Soup of the Day

SECOND COURSE

All entrées served with pommes potatoes + carrots

  • Chicken Marsala
  • Potato Crusted Halibut 
  • Petite Filet 

THIRD COURSE

  • Snickerdoodle Cheesecake
  • Flourless Chocolate Cake
  • Sorbet (available upon request for allergies)
  • 00

    days

  • 00

    hours

  • 00

    minutes

  • 00

    seconds

Tags:

Date

Dec 21 2025

Cost

$110.00

Location

The Eldred Preserve
The Eldred Preserve
1040 State Rte 55, Eldred, NY 12732